Why People Have Special Jobs

Several years ago, my oldest son and I were discussing economics and financial markets when I recalled a cartoon I had watched in elementary school. The film did a remarkable job explaining how specialization and trade make everyone more productive.

I couldn't remember the title, only that it involved a caveman who made a spinning top for his son. When the other children wanted one, their fathers offered to trade the surplus from their own specialties, such as hunting and fishing, for tops of their own.

The trades allowed the toymaker to spend more time making tops instead of hunting, fishing, and gathering everything he needed himself. By specializing in what they did best and trading with one another, the entire village became more productive.

My son, a vintage film and animation enthusiast, has searched for the cartoon ever since without success. I've tried many times myself. This week, after another prompt from him, I finally found it!

The film is titled Why People Have Special Jobs, produced by Stephen Bosustow for the Learning Corporation of America. Special thanks to A/V Geeks for preserving and digitizing old 16mm films like this one.

It's worth watching. The lessons from this 1970s cartoon still hold up today.

Source: A/V Geeks

The cartoon initially illustrates the simple economic principle that people benefit when they specialize in activities they're particularly good at. Economists call this an absolute advantage.

But the more interesting lesson involves a less intuitive concept known as comparative advantage.

In the cartoon, the best hunter is better at hunting than the toymaker, and the best fisherman catches more fish. Trading with them is an obvious choice.

Then a young boy, who has no father to trade on his behalf, offers to gather wood for the toymaker in exchange for a top.

The toymaker could almost certainly gather wood faster than the boy. He's bigger, stronger, and more experienced. In other words, the toymaker has an absolute advantage in wood collecting.

Yet the trade still makes sense.

Why? Opportunity cost.

Every minute the toymaker spends gathering wood is a minute he can't spend making tops. Even though he's better at gathering wood, the time he saves by doing it himself is worth less than the tops he could produce instead.

The boy has a comparative advantage because gathering wood comes at a lower opportunity cost for him because it’s one of the few tasks he can offer in exchange.

Fast-forward fifty-plus years, and this distinction has become increasingly relevant for business owners.

AI now allows us to build software, create marketing campaigns, analyze financial statements, and perform countless other tasks that once required specialized training and experience.

The productivity gap between specialists and nonspecialists is narrowing across many activities. Suddenly, doing more ourselves seems increasingly attractive. Are we returning to the beginning of the cartoon, when everyone did everything themselves?

Definitely not everything.

AI is changing what we can do ourselves. But whether we should do so still depends on what we must give up

Business owners who fail to recognize that distinction risk becoming remarkably productive at the expense of focusing on the areas where opportunity costs are skyrocketing.

The Comparative Advantage Trap

Software is a great example. AI has revolutionized software development. Until recently, building an application required either deep technical expertise or capital. Now, anyone with a $20 per month ChatGPT subscription can build a fully functioning application in a weekend.

The absolute advantage between software developers and the rest of us has decreased dramatically.

Because now everyone can build software, the supply of competing applications has skyrocketed. Now, the really hard part of selling software is distribution.

AI has reduced the cost of building software while potentially increasing the opportunity cost of building it yourself. You might be better off outsourcing the development and spending all of your extra time and resources developing distribution channels and acquiring customers.

Also, the AI tools that made you more productive have also increased the productivity of professional developers significantly. You are likely to get way more for your money than you would have just a few years ago. Said differently, the absolute advantage between you and a professional developer might still be bigger than you perceive.

No doubt AI has changed both the cost to perform certain activities and the value of what we could be doing instead.

Understanding both sides of the equation is the key to deciding what to bring in-house and what to outsource.

So how do you decide?

The Two-Sided Test

The Two-Sided Test is simple but not easy. You’re simply comparing the savings from doing the work yourself with the value of what you're potentially giving up.

The first side is often easier and more concrete. The second is less clear and where the trap can lie. We tend to over-value things that are more easily measurable.

Side 1: What are the relative savings from doing the work myself?

The first side is often very tangible. Let’s assume you have a service business like a small HVAC provider. Given how AI might improve your business you might consider:

  • Have AI help me with my bookkeeping or continue paying my bookkeeper $1,000 per month. Assume it takes me five hours per month.

  • Hire a web developer to build my website for $10,000, or build it myself over two weekends with a day per month of maintenance.

There are countless more as we figure out what we can do with agents and agent workflows.

We know one side of the equation, let’s examine the other.

Side 2: What are my opportunity costs?

One of the first questions I always ask a new client is “What is your typical customer’s lifetime value (LTV)?” Put more simply, how much will a customer spend with you over the life of the business relationship?

The average customer LTV for an HVAC company is $15,000. LTV is typically stated as revenue. Let’s assume the LTV in gross profit terms is $5,000. Now we have a relatively straightforward comparison.

The question the HVAC owner should ask is whether spending an extra five hours per month on marketing and lead generation could yield even one extra customer? If so, it would make sense to keep the bookkeeper and focus on marketing and sales.

The website could be viewed the same way. The owner could set up numerous ad campaigns or create dozens of social media posts over two weekends of work. If they spent one day per month cold calling instead of maintaining their website, that could yield multiple customers as well. Those activities would only need to generate just two additional customers to break even.

Also, if the HVAC owner doesn’t have a website at all, any website might be preferable to none. If they have one, hiring a professional web developer might be the best investment as a well-designed website with good SEO (search engine optimization) could easily yield multiple new customers.

The point is not to stop at Side 1 because you believe you're saving $1,000 by firing your bookkeeper and firing up ChatGPT. You also need to consider what you're giving up and how much those alternatives could be worth to your business.

The Next Step

AI is making it possible for business owners to do more than ever before. But just because you can do something yourself doesn't mean you should.

Identify one or two activities you're currently outsourcing that AI could help you bring in-house. Then apply the Two-Sided Test.

First, calculate what you'd actually save in time and money. Next, identify what you could accomplish with that same time if you continued outsourcing. Be specific. Could you acquire another customer, improve an existing relationship, or pursue a growth opportunity?

AI can definitely make you more productive. But will it make you extraordinarily productive at activities that aren't the best use of your time to begin with?

Remember, the spinning-top maker didn't trade with the boy because he couldn't gather wood. He traded because his time was more valuable making tops.

AI may change how quickly you can gather wood. It doesn't eliminate the need to decide whether you should.

My goal with The Leap is to provide you each Saturday with the knowledge, tools and lessons learned to help you get started and keep going toward building your future. 

Whether you are making the leap to startups, solo-entrepreneurship, freelancing, side hustles or other creative ventures, the tools and strategies to succeed in each are similar.